I’ve heard many stories linked to 1956: of bravery, of hope turned to despair, of escape and exile. I’ve said before that it can sometimes seem as though everyone took part and everyone was a hero. But life is rarely that black and white, and 1956 brings the complexities of human relationships into particularly sharp focus. There is the survivor’s guilt of those who fled to the West, and the sense of judgment that several returnees have told me they felt from those who stayed behind.

Presumably, Ukrainians are experiencing something similar now, or will once, God willing, the war ends and peace returns. How welcome will men of fighting age feel if and when they return home?

The story of 1956 that resonates most strongly with me is my father-in-law’s. It hits home because, as he told me, he wasn’t the hero of the story, just a young man living through difficult times. He had been swept up in the student protests in Szeged that preceded the uprising. On Oct. 26, he was near the front of a demonstration when Hungarian soldiers opened fire. Accounts of the incident vary, but some suggest the shots were intended as warnings. What is known is that bullets ricocheted off pavement and buildings, striking the crowd, killing one person and injuring 16.

My father-in-law said all his revolutionary zeal drained away as he realized the consequences of unarmed students confronting professional soldiers with guns. He went home in shock and, by his own admission, took no further part in the uprising. Raised in the countryside, he had witnessed the communists marching his family off their farm, one of his strongest early memories. He was a hunter, yet disliked war films and hated the idea of toy guns for children.

Around the same time that my father-in-law was discovering the brutal reality of what bullets can do to flesh, another young man, the brother of the woman who would become my mother-in-law, was having his own run-in with authority. In his case, though, it was his parents. He and his friends were too young to participate actively in the uprising, but his parents feared he might be running errands for the rebels. After begging him not to, they eventually resorted to locking him in his bedroom. Who are we to judge? Desperate times call for desperate measures.

Americans call those who came of age during the Great Depression and fought in World War II the Greatest Generation. If anyone can judge the choices people made in difficult times, perhaps it is them rather than us. But they reacted to adversity in no more uniform a way than the Silent Generation that followed, the Baby Boomers, the Millennials, or any generation before or since.

Life is complicated. It always is. Perhaps it is best simply to remember all those who lived through 1956, rather than judge how they responded.

Robin Marshall

Editor-in-chief

This editorial was first published in the Budapest Business Journal print issue of October 19, 2026.